Arsenic: Drinking water with arsenic for many years can cause skin problems and raises the risk of some cancers, including skin, bladder and lung cancer. It has no color, taste or smell. Source
Nitrate and coliform bacteria look unlikely here, but they have no taste or smell, so they are still worth a test.
Everyday problems
Manganese: Manganese leaves black or brown stains and can make water taste bitter or metallic. At high levels it can also affect health, especially for babies, so use other water for baby formula if your well is high. Source
Iron: Iron leaves orange or brown stains on sinks, toilets and laundry, can make water taste metallic, and can clog pipes and fixtures. It is not a health risk.
USGS predicts typical nitrate around 0.1 parts per million (as nitrogen) in private wells here (compare the EPA limit of 10 parts per million (as nitrogen)).
If a test finds coliform bacteria, find and fix how water gets in, then have the well disinfected (shock chlorination) and test again. If it comes back, the usual fix is a UV disinfection system, like the Pulsar Max Plus UV Disinfection System ($2,290–$2,540).
USGS estimates about an 8% chance that a private well here has manganese above the EPA health advisory level of 0.3 parts per million. At that level it can harm health, especially for babies.
0 of 17 wells tested since 2001 were above the World Health Organization's taste level of 200 parts per million; 5 of 17 were above the EPA guidance level of 20 parts per million for people on a very low-sodium diet.
If a test finds sulfate over the taste or staining level, the usual fix is the same as for Arsenic (above).
Other substances tested
Radon17 wells6%LowModerate risk
Water tests from agencies
1 of 17 wells tested since 2001 were above the higher radon level the EPA proposed, 4,000 picocuries per liter (a measure of radioactivity; there is no federal limit).
If a test finds nitrite over the limit, the usual fix is the same as for Arsenic (above).
PFASacross the countyUSGS estimateabout 24% chanceLowNot rated
USGS estimate
USGS estimates about a 24% chance that a private well here has some PFAS ("forever chemicals") in it. This counts any amount found; most are far below EPA limits.
Less than 1% of households on private wells here (about 110 homes) live within 1 mile of a known PFAS source (a site where PFAS was found, a reported PFAS release or firefighting-foam spill, or a PFAS maker, from EPA data). That does not mean their wells are affected, but it is a good reason to test. Source: EPA PFAS Analytic Tools.
If a test finds PFAS over the limit, the usual fix is the same as for Lead (above).
How we rate: High risk means 1 in 10 or more tested wells were over a health limit, or a USGS estimate of 20% or more. Moderate means 2 in 100 or more; Low, fewer. Confidence is High with 100 or more wells tested, Moderate with 20 to 99, and Low with fewer or a computer estimate only. With too few tests to judge, the county reads Risk Unknown. Stains, scale and taste are rated on their own and don't change the county's risk.
Check your ZIP code
Well water can differ from one part of a county to the next. Enter your ZIP code to see what the U.S. Geological Survey estimates for arsenic and nitrate in wells around you.
Half of the private wells on record here are more than 300 feet deep, and the middle half are 230 to 410 feet deep (from 3,697 state well records). Source: U.S. Groundwater Well Database.
Half of the private wells on record here were drilled by 2009 (from 3,603 state well records). Source: U.S. Groundwater Well Database.
About 2% of households on private wells here (about 550 homes) live within 1 mile of a contaminated site on the state's or EPA's list. That does not mean their wells are affected, but it is a good reason to test. Source: New York environmental remediation sites, NYSDEC.
Less than 1% of this county sits on limestone and similar rock with cracks and caves (called karst), where bacteria and nitrate can travel quickly underground. Another small part (less than 1%) has this kind of rock buried deeper underground. Source: USGS map of limestone and similar rock.
Radon in indoor air (EPA map): Zone 1 – highest potential. Source: EPA Map of Radon Zones.Why it matters: Radon can get into well water too. Ask your lab about a radon test for water, especially in the highest zone.
Radon in indoor air: about 28% of homes tested here (about 250 homes, 1987 to 2026) had radon at or above the level where the EPA recommends fixing the home. These are homes whose owners chose to test. Source: Home radon tests, New York State Department of Health.Why it matters: Radon can get into well water too. Ask your lab about a radon test for water.
Since 2000, FEMA has declared 8 flood or hurricane disasters that included this county, most recently in 2021. Source: FEMA disaster declarations.Why it matters: Floodwater can carry bacteria and chemicals into a well. Test your water after any flood.
Since 2000, at least half of this county was in drought about 3% of the time, most recently with severe drought in 2024. Drought lowers the water table, and shallow wells can run low or dry. Source: U.S. Drought Monitor.
These are facts about the whole county. None of them means a particular well has a problem; only a test can tell you that.
Well water testing in Sullivan County
The only way to know what is in your well is to test it. The certified labs nearest Sullivan County are listed below. The closest is Ag Environmental Rsc LLC Dba Sullivan County Labs in Ferndale, about 3 miles away. A mail-in kit is another option. Test every year for bacteria and nitrate, and here, also ask for arsenic, manganese and iron.
Order a test kitTap Score Advanced Well Water Test
A mail-in test from certified labs for more than 100 substances, with results in about a week.
These labs serve well owners across Sullivan County, including Barryville, Bethel, Bloomingburg, Bridgeville, Callicoon, Cochecton, Delaware, Eldred, Fallsburg, Forestburgh, Fremont, Grahamsville, Hankins, Highland, Hortonville, Hurleyville, Jeffersonville, Kauneonga Lake, Kiamesha Lake, Lake Huntington, Liberty, Livingston Manor, Loch Sheldrake, Lumberland, Mamakating, Mongaup Valley, Monticello, Mountain Dale, Narrowsburg, Neversink, Rock Hill, Rockland, Roscoe, Smallwood, South Fallsburg, Swan Lake, Thompson, Tusten, White Lake, Woodbourne, Woodridge, Wurtsboro and Wurtsboro Hills.
These labs are certified by New York to test drinking water for bacteria. For other tests, ask the lab what it is certified for. See the state's list.
Rules about testing
New York has no statewide rule that makes you test a home well, though the state health department recommends testing new wells. Some counties require a test when a home is sold. Source
Federal rules and home loans (6)
No federal law makes you test your own well. EPA and CDC recommend testing every year for bacteria, nitrate, pH and dissolved solids. Source
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans don't require a well test. Your lender or local law may still require one. Source
If you buy with an FHA loan, the lender must confirm the well water is safe. A test is required for new homes and when there is a known problem. The results must be less than 180 days old. Source
With an FHA loan, a well that is closer to a septic system than HUD allows can still qualify if it meets local rules and a water test shows the water is safe. Source
If you buy with a USDA guaranteed loan and the home has a well, a health department or state-certified lab must test the water. The report must be less than 180 days old at closing. Refinances don't need a test. Source
If you buy with a VA loan and the home has a well, a neutral third party must test the water. You can't take the sample yourself. Results are good for 90 days. Source
New York has no statewide well test rule. Westchester, Rockland and Suffolk counties require a test when a home is sold, and some towns (East Fishkill, Wappinger) and counties (Erie, Chautauqua) have their own.
Type in the numbers from your lab report and our free planner tells you what to fix first, which problems one system can handle together, and what you don't need to buy. Your numbers stay in your browser.
Some of these are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our picks do not affect what the data says.
Ready to test your well?
A mail-in kit or a certified lab near Sullivan County can test your water.
Download the data behind this page for New York. It is free to reuse if you credit YourWaterReport.
To cite this page: YourWaterReport, "Sullivan County, NY Wells: 28% of 25 Wells High in Manganese," https://yourwaterreport.com/states/ny/sullivan-county/, data updated November 16, 2026.
This product uses the Federal Emergency Management Agency's OpenFEMA API, but is not endorsed by FEMA. The Federal Government or FEMA cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from the Agency's website(s). Data: OpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries v2 (https://www.fema.gov/api/open/v2/DisasterDeclarationsSummaries).
Environmental Remediation Sites, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (data.ny.gov).
Radon Test Results By County: Beginning 1987, New York State Department of Health.
The U.S. Drought Monitor is jointly produced by the National Drought Mitigation Center at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, the United States Department of Agriculture, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Data courtesy of NDMC.
Lin, C.-Y., A. Miller, M. Waqar, L. Marston (2024). A Database of Groundwater Wells in the United States, HydroShare, https://doi.org/10.4211/hs.8b02895f02c14dd1a749bcc5584a5c55. Licensed under CC BY 4.0.