Home › Indiana › Sullivan County

Sullivan County, IN Well Water: Test for Nitrate & Manganese

Data updated November 12, 2026. Covers private wells, not public water systems.

Print fact sheet

High Risk
Wells here often exceed a health limit Based on 7 wells tested Confidence: Low
Top concerns in this county Also test every year for bacteria and nitrate.
Testing strongly recommended Test your well now →Mail-in kit sold on Amazon, results in about a weekFind a certified lab

What this means for you

Your health

Nitrate: Nitrate is most dangerous for babies under 6 months. It can keep their blood from carrying enough oxygen. Use other water for baby formula if your well is high. It has no color, taste or smell. Boiling does not remove it; it makes it stronger. Source

Fixes: If a test finds nitrate over the limit, the usual fix is a reverse osmosis system, like the American Made Reverse Osmosis System. All products on this page.

Arsenic looks unlikely here, but it has no taste or smell, so it is still worth a test.

Everyday problems

Hardness: Hard water leaves white scale on faucets, glasses and inside water heaters, and soap lathers poorly. It is not a health risk.

Sodium: Sodium makes water taste salty. It matters most for people on a low-salt diet; a water softener also adds sodium.

Manganese: Manganese leaves black or brown stains and can make water taste bitter or metallic. At high levels it can also affect health, especially for babies, so use other water for baby formula if your well is high. Source

Iron: Iron leaves orange or brown stains on sinks, toilets and laundry, can make water taste metallic, and can clog pipes and fixtures. It is not a health risk.

Fixes: If a test finds hard water, the usual fix is a water softener, like the Matrixx Smart Metered Water Softener. It also handles small amounts of manganese and iron. If a test finds high sodium, the usual fix is a reverse osmosis system, like the American Made Reverse Osmosis System. If a test finds manganese or iron over the taste or staining level, the usual fix is an iron and sulfur filter, like the Matrixx InFusion Iron & Sulfur Eradication System. All products on this page.

Find out what's in your well

The only way to know is to test. For a well in Sullivan County, make sure the test covers:

  • Nitrate
  • Sodium
  • Manganese
  • Iron
  • Bacteria and nitrate, every year

What tests found in Sullivan County

Over a health limitOver a taste or staining levelFound, under the limitUnder the limit or not foundComputer estimate
SubstanceTestedOver the limitResultsConfidenceRisk
Health concerns
Nitrate 7 wells 29% Low High risk

Nitrate across Indiana →

Water tests from agencies

2 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the EPA limit of 10 parts per million (as nitrogen).

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

USGS estimate

USGS predicts typical nitrate around 0.4 parts per million (as nitrogen) in private wells here (compare the EPA limit of 10 parts per million (as nitrogen)).

Source: USGS nitrate estimate for private wells (computer model), 1988–2018

If a test finds nitrate over the limit, the usual fix is a reverse osmosis system, like the American Made Reverse Osmosis System ($599–$799).

Arsenic 7 wells 0% Low Low risk

Arsenic across Indiana →

Water tests from agencies

0 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the EPA limit of 10 parts per billion.

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

Water tests from agencies

0 of 18 wells tested since 1990 were above the EPA limit of 10 parts per billion.

Source: Well water tests from USGS, EPA and state agencies (Water Quality Portal), 1990

USGS estimate

USGS estimates about an 8% chance that a private well here has arsenic above the EPA limit of 10 parts per billion.

Source: USGS arsenic estimate for private wells (computer model), 1970–2013

If a test finds arsenic over the limit, the usual fix is the same as for Nitrate (above).

Lead 7 wells 0% Low Low risk

Water tests from agencies

0 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the EPA action level of 15 parts per billion.

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

If a test finds lead over the limit, the usual fix is a whole-house lead and PFAS filter, like the Pioneer Whole-House Lead, Cyst & PFOA/PFOS Removal System ($1,669–$2,364). Running the tap before drinking helps.

Everyday water problems
Hardness 20 wells 95% Moderate Very common

Hard Water across Indiana →

Scale on fixtures and in water heaters, and soap that lathers poorly.

Water tests from agencies

19 of 20 wells tested since 1990 were above the USGS level for hard water (120 parts per million).

Source: Well water tests from USGS, EPA and state agencies (Water Quality Portal), 1990–1991

If a test finds hard water, the usual fix is a water softener, like the Matrixx Smart Metered Water Softener ($1,467–$1,775).

Sodium 7 wells 29% Low Very common

A salty taste at higher levels.

Water tests from agencies

2 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the World Health Organization's taste level of 200 parts per million; 2 of 7 were above the EPA guidance level of 20 parts per million for people on a very low-sodium diet.

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

If a test finds high sodium, the usual fix is the same as for Nitrate (above).

Manganese 18 wells 17% Low Common

Manganese across Indiana →

Black or brown staining and a bitter, metallic taste.

Water tests from agencies

3 of 18 wells tested since 1990 were above the EPA taste-and-staining guideline of 0.05 parts per million.

Source: Well water tests from USGS, EPA and state agencies (Water Quality Portal), 1990

USGS estimate

USGS estimates about a 27% chance that a private well here has manganese above the EPA health advisory level of 0.3 parts per million. At that level it can harm health, especially for babies.

Source: USGS manganese estimate for private wells (computer model), 1988–2018

If a test finds manganese over the taste or staining level, the usual fix is an iron and sulfur filter, like the Matrixx InFusion Iron & Sulfur Eradication System ($3,295–$3,395).

Iron 7 wells 14% Low Common

Iron across Indiana →

Brown or orange staining, a metallic taste and clogged fixtures.

Water tests from agencies

1 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the EPA taste-and-staining guideline of 0.3 parts per million.

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

Water tests from agencies

2 of 18 wells tested since 1990 were above the EPA taste-and-staining guideline of 0.3 parts per million.

Source: Well water tests from USGS, EPA and state agencies (Water Quality Portal), 1990

If a test finds iron over the taste or staining level, the usual fix is the same as for Manganese (above).

Chloride 7 wells 0% Low Rare
Sulfate 7 wells 0% Low Rare
Other substances tested
Fluoride 20 wells 0% Moderate Low risk
Mercury 7 wells 0% Low Low risk

Water tests from agencies

0 of 7 wells tested since 2012 were above the EPA limit of 2 parts per billion.

Source: Statewide private well sampling, Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2012–2014

If a test finds mercury over the limit, the usual fix is a reverse osmosis system, like the American Made Reverse Osmosis System ($599–$799).

PFASacross the county USGS estimate about 15% chance Low Not rated

USGS estimate

USGS estimates about a 15% chance that a private well here has some PFAS ("forever chemicals") in it. This counts any amount found; most are far below EPA limits.

Source: USGS PFAS estimate for private wells (computer model), 2019–2022

No households on private wells here live within 1 mile of a known PFAS source (a site where PFAS was found, a reported PFAS release or firefighting-foam spill, or a PFAS maker, from EPA data). Source: EPA PFAS Analytic Tools.

If a test finds PFAS over the limit, the usual fix is the same as for Lead (above).

How we rate: High risk means 1 in 10 or more tested wells were over a health limit, or a USGS estimate of 20% or more. Moderate means 2 in 100 or more; Low, fewer. Confidence is High with 100 or more wells tested, Moderate with 20 to 99, and Low with fewer or a computer estimate only. With too few tests to judge, the county reads Risk Unknown. Stains, scale and taste are rated on their own and don't change the county's risk.

Check your ZIP code

Well water can differ from one part of a county to the next. Enter your ZIP code to see what the U.S. Geological Survey estimates for arsenic and nitrate in wells around you.

About wells here

These are facts about the whole county. None of them means a particular well has a problem; only a test can tell you that.

Well water testing in Sullivan County

The only way to know what is in your well is to test it. The certified labs nearest Sullivan County are listed below. The closest is McCoy & McCoy Laboratories, a Pace Analytical Services Company in Farmersburg, about 11 miles away. A mail-in kit is another option. Test every year for bacteria and nitrate, and here, also ask for sodium and manganese.

Order a test kit Tap Score Advanced Well Water Test

A mail-in test from certified labs for more than 100 substances, with results in about a week.

Sold on Amazon · mailed to your home

Order a Tap Score Test →
Nearest certified lab McCoy & McCoy Laboratories, a Pace Analytical Services Company

P.O. Box 569, Farmersburg

About 11 miles away · 812-696-5076

Certified for drinking water tests

Call a lab first to ask which tests it runs and how to get a sample bottle.

Every certified lab in Indiana

These labs serve well owners across Sullivan County, including Carlisle, Dugger, Farmersburg, Hymera, Merom, Shelburn and Sullivan, and Cass, Curry, Fairbanks, Gill, Haddon, Hamilton, Jackson, Jefferson and Turman townships.

These labs are certified by Indiana for the tests shown. Before you order, check the state's list for the tests you need. See the state's list.

Rules about testing

  • Indiana has no statewide rule for testing private wells, even when a home is sold. The state health department recommends testing at least once a year. Source
Federal rules and home loans (6)
  • No federal law makes you test your own well. EPA and CDC recommend testing every year for bacteria, nitrate, pH and dissolved solids. Source
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans don't require a well test. Your lender or local law may still require one. Source
  • If you buy with an FHA loan, the lender must confirm the well water is safe. A test is required for new homes and when there is a known problem. The results must be less than 180 days old. Source
  • With an FHA loan, a well that is closer to a septic system than HUD allows can still qualify if it meets local rules and a water test shows the water is safe. Source
  • If you buy with a USDA guaranteed loan and the home has a well, a health department or state-certified lab must test the water. The report must be less than 180 days old at closing. Refinances don't need a test. Source
  • If you buy with a VA loan and the home has a well, a neutral third party must test the water. You can't take the sample yourself. Results are good for 90 days. Source

Some Indiana counties require a bacteria test before a new home's well is used; those county ordinances have not been read one by one (2026-10-24).

Local help

For up-to-date local news about wells and water testing, check the Sullivan County Health Department website.

Local health departments

From the Directory of Indiana Local Health Departments (Indiana Department of Health).

State programs

Products on this page

Test first, then fix only what your test finds. Certified labs near Sullivan County are listed above.

Tests

Test kit Tap Score Advanced Well Water Test

A mail-in test from certified labs for more than 100 substances, with results in about a week.

Sold on Amazon · mailed to your home

Order a Tap Score Test →

Fixes, if a test finds a problem

Usual fix American Made Reverse Osmosis System

For Nitrate, Arsenic, Sodium, Chloride, Sulfate, Fluoride, Mercury.

$599–$799

View product →
Usual fix Pioneer Whole-House Lead, Cyst & PFOA/PFOS Removal System

For Lead, PFAS.

$1,669–$2,364

View product →
Usual fix Matrixx Smart Metered Water Softener

For Hardness. Also an option for Manganese, Iron.

$1,467–$1,775

View product →
Usual fix Matrixx InFusion Iron & Sulfur Eradication System

For Manganese, Iron.

$3,295–$3,395

View product →
Another option APEC ROES-50 Essence 5-Stage Reverse Osmosis System

An option for Nitrate, Arsenic, Lead, Sodium, Chloride, Sulfate, Fluoride, Mercury, PFAS.

See price on Amazon

View on Amazon →
Another option Eddy Electronic Water Descaler (salt-free)

An option for Hardness.

See price on Amazon

View on Amazon →
Another option Matrixx Ultimate Iron, Sulfur & Softening System

An option for Hardness, Manganese, Iron.

$4,905–$5,322

View product →
Another option iSpring WGB32BM Whole House Iron & Manganese Filter

An option for Manganese, Iron.

See price on Amazon

View on Amazon →
Another option Bodyguard Plus Whole House Backwashing Carbon Filter

An option for Mercury.

$1,331–$2,073

View product →

Need help deciding?

Type in the numbers from your lab report and our free planner tells you what to fix first, which problems one system can handle together, and what you don't need to buy. Your numbers stay in your browser.

Make a treatment plan

Some of these are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our picks do not affect what the data says.

Ready to test your well?

A mail-in kit or a certified lab near Sullivan County can test your water.

Sullivan County: High RiskTest your well now

For health departments, realtors and groups

Free ways to share what wells in Sullivan County show:

  • Print or hand out the one-page fact sheet (PDF), with a code that opens this page.
  • Add this to your website: a free card about wells in Sullivan County that updates itself.
  • Download the data behind this page for Indiana. It is free to reuse if you credit YourWaterReport.
  • To cite this page: YourWaterReport, "Sullivan County, IN Well Water: Test for Nitrate & Manganese," https://yourwaterreport.com/states/in/sullivan-county/, data updated November 12, 2026.

Sources and dates

All 16 data sources and when we retrieved them

Required credits

  • This product uses the Federal Emergency Management Agency's OpenFEMA API, but is not endorsed by FEMA. The Federal Government or FEMA cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from the Agency's website(s). Data: OpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries v2 (https://www.fema.gov/api/open/v2/DisasterDeclarationsSummaries).
  • State Cleanup and Leaking Underground Storage Tank sites, Indiana Department of Environmental Management; Superfund sites, U.S. EPA.
  • Statewide Groundwater Monitoring Network, Indiana Department of Environmental Management.
  • The U.S. Drought Monitor is jointly produced by the National Drought Mitigation Center at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, the United States Department of Agriculture, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Data courtesy of NDMC.

How we get our numbers · Download the data